Monday, November 16, 2026

Sabito Restaurant in Lytle Park Hotel, Cincinatti

Sabito Restaurant in Lytle Park Hotel, Cincinatti

Continuing our travels heading north, we stayed over in Cincinnati at The Lytle Park Hotel, a Marriott Autograph Collection property. Following our spectacular stay and dinner in the on-site Lilous Brasserie at Cleo Hotel, Knoxville, we stayed and dined in another boutique hotel and restaurant on our route back to Chicago/Naperille. 

We stayed at The Lytle Park Hotel, situated in a classic 1909 building in downtown Cincinnati historic Mt. Adams neighborhood, adjacent picturesque Lytle Park, the Taft Museum of Art, and other historic buildings, in the shadow of the downtown skyline.

We dined at the on-site Sabito Restaurant which promotes “‘Northern Italian Cuisine with an Air of European Sophistication” - homemade pastas, scratch-made sauces and hand-selected, perfectly seared steaks, finished in our infrared broiler. Along with promising the freshest seafood, Subito offers brick oven pizzas, a raw bar and traditional antipasti.” 

The Executive Chef of Sabito at The Lytle Park Hotel is Joseph Helm. Joe graduated from The Pennsylvania Culinary Institute in 2006. 

Joe was Executive Chef & Co Owner at Panino, Executive Sous Chef at Marriott International, Execute Chef at Celestial Steakhouse & Executive Chef of Mt. Adams Fish House. 

Helm joined Pyramid Hotel Group (PHG) in August of 2019, starting as Chef de Cuisine. He was an instrumental part of the opening team of The Lytle Park Hotel, taking over as Executive Chef in 2021 after being named "Manager of the Year" at The Lytle Park Hotel in 2020. 

Sabito has an elegant formal dining room adjacent the lobby bar.


We chose to dine in the adjoining ‘All Seasons’ dining room overlooking a courtyard with gas fire pit and cityscape views of the adjacent Lytle Park, the nearbyTaft Museum of Art and downtown skyline.  



The Subito menu features Italian cuisine as well as steaks and various seafood selections. 

We were drawn to and unfortunately both selected the “Seasonal Selection Prix Fix Special Dinner”.  

Prix Fixe Menu - 

Insalata - Roasted Beet - arugula + pickled mustard seed + goat cheese + lemon oregano vinaigrette

Secondi - Baked Clams - n'duja, san marzano tomato, arneis, garlic pangritata, charred focaccia 

Piatto Pincipale - Black Cod grilled asparagus, saffron.

 

Insalata - Roasted Beet - arugula + pickled mustard seed + goat cheese + lemon oregano vinaigrette.


The beets were tasty and plentiful but Linda was put off by wilted and somewhat less than ideally fresh arugula. 

Secondi - Baked Clams - n'duja, san marzano tomato, arneis, garlic pangritata, charred focaccia. These would’ve been better had they been served warmer, ideally hot. They were tasty as was the sauce to be mopped up in the toast points.  


Piatto Pincipale - Black Cod grilled asparagus, saffron.

Regrettably this was mundane and uninspiring, rather tasteless, and lacking creativity. The fish was not hot and was rather bland. The saffron added little to enhance the overall experience. Perhaps we’re jaded having spent much of the last two months on the Emerald Coast, Destin, FL panhandle, with a dozen seafood restaurants serving the daily fresh catch, featured throughout these pages over that period.


Like the menu, the wine list features a selection of Italian as well as American producers/labels. 

There is a selection of wines by the glass - WBTG - nine whites and 13 reds, as well as some sparkling and dessert wines. 

The wine list is split between Italian and American selections with broad range of price options from modest value based labels at $50 to ultra-premium selections such as Italian Tignanello at $450 and Sassicaia at $525, and American BV Georges de Latour at $425, Opus Overture at $459, and Opus One in multiple vintages from $650 to $750. 

The white wines available to accompany our seafood selection, ranging from $50 to $150, included six each Italian labels, US Chardonnays and US Sauvignon Blancs, and eight ‘Diverse Whites’, plus other selections.

Lacking a desired or interesting Chardonnay, with limited choices of Rombauer or Far Niente, we ordered a California (Napa, Sonoma, Santa Barbara) Chardonnay with which we’d had a positive experience previously, with a bottle gifted to me by a Mentee while at IBM.

Orin Swift Mannequin California Chardonnay 2021

I’ve written previously in these pages about winemaker David Phinny and his broad portfolio of nearly two dozen Orin Swift labels and rather bizarre branding with weird and oft times creepy labels, excerpted below.  

Note - Please forgive the missing photos on earlier posts while I am transitioning my production website to a new platform. 

This is a label from winemaker producer David Phinney, who is known for creating the widely popular Prisoner brand that he first created back in 1998. Phinney's interest in wines dates back to 1995 when on a lark, David Swift Phinney took a friend up on an offer and went to Florence, Italy to spend a semester “studying”. During that time, he was introduced to wine, how it was made, and he got hooked. After graduation from university, he  eventually landed a job at Robert Mondavi Winery in 1997 starting as a temporary harvest worker. 


Deciding that if he was going to work this hard, it would eventually have to be for himself, Phinny founded Orin Swift Cellars in 1998, named after Orin, his father’s middle name, and Swift, his mother’s maiden name. With two tons of zinfandel and not much else, he spent the next decade making wine for others as well as himself. He made the first Prisoner wine in 2000 with a 385 case production and continuing growing production, his reputation and his brand to an inconic label and portfolio with a wide cult-like following. The widely popular Prisoner label and brand had grown to a wide selection of carefully crafted wines - blends from the best vineyards and appellations across the leading regions of California.  

Phinney sold the Zinfandel blend and a few other labels comprising The Prisoner Wine Company to Huneeus Vintners in 2010, owners of the premium Quintessa brand. Huneeus later sold it to Constellation Brands in 2016 who spun off Orin Swift to E. & J. Gallo Winery, although David stayed on and remained the brand's winemaker. When Constellation bought The Prisoner Wine Company in 2016, case production had increased to 165,000 and they paid $285 million for the brand. 

Following his non-compete sabatical after selling The Prisoner Brand, Phinney released his follow on label, 'Eight Years in the Desert', for the period of time since he had produced the original Prisoner red blend. He built up his new brand with labels that compared with those of his earlier portfolio. 
  • Orin Swift, Eight Years in the Desert vs The Prisoner Wine Company, The Prisoner.
  • Orin Swift, Mercury Head Cabernet Sauvignon vs The Prisoner Wine Company, Derange Red Blend.
  • Orin Swift, Slander Pinot Noir vs The Prisoner Wine Company, Eternally Silenced Pinot Noir.
  • Orin Swift, Palermo Cabernet Sauvignon vs The Prisoner Wine Company, Cuttings Cabernet Sauvignon.

Orin Swift became almost as well-known for its artistic and mysterious labels featuring photography, pastiche, collage and street art, making them stand out and helping to tell the story of each wine. 

Frankly, many of the Orin Swift labels are weird and in some/many cases creepy; The Prisoner family of wines, Red Blend, White Blend and Chardonnay, Blank Stare, Blindfold, China Doll, Machete, Palermo and tonights’ label, The Mannequin. 

Orin Swift Cellars Mannequin California Chardonnay 2021 


As featured in an earlier blogpost, the wines of Dave Phinney and Orin-Swift Cellars are distinctive in their branding and packaging with some of the more intriguing and unique labels and wine names. Perhaps best known for the somewhat macabre “Prisoner” (no longer owned by Dave, although he remains a consultant) and “Papillon” with its stark black and white photograph of rough-hewn fingers (left), Phinney composes his rather mysterious label designs from a collection to a collage of a variety of photographs.

His wines are as distinctive as his labels. They tend to be full-flavored, forward, intense, firm structured wines. He mixes a melange of varietals from a variety of appellations and vineyards to form the distinct profile and personality of each label. They are not for the feint of heart.

After graduating college he spent a short time at Robert Mondavi Winery before founding Orin Swift Cellars. From his original release based on purchased Zinfandel grapes, he has added Cabernet Sauvignon, Sauvignon Blanc and eventually extended the range to Grenache, Petite Sirah, and Syrah.

Orin Swift eventually purchased forty-eight acres in the hills above Oakville to plant and develop. They also recently purchased some vineyards and a winery in the steep hillsides of the Roussillon, near Maury in the French Pyrénées planted in 60-100 year old Grenache, with a small percentage of Syrah and Carignane. Commuting between California and France, Dave lives with his wife and children in St. Helena, CA.

The 2021 Orin Swift Cellars Mannequin is a rich, mineral driven full-bodied California Chardonnay blended from fruit sourced in the Sonoma County Russian River Valley, Napa Valley Atlas Peak, and Santa Barbara County Santa Maria Valley, and a small touch (2.6%) of Viognier.

It was barrel-fermented and aged sur lie for 8 months in French oak (23% new). It is widely available as over 11,000 cases were produced. 

Robert Parker’s Wine Advocate rated this release 90 points with 4.0–4.1/5 in community ratings on Wine.com and Vivino.

Winemaker Notes - “A blinding white gold and a chartreuse shimmer in the glass, the 2021 Mannequin opens with opulent, beguiling aromatics. Ripe golden apple, concentrated jasmine, citrus notes and a touch of cream and fresh brioche emerge. The entry is bright yet with a bit of weight; similar aromatic notes come through on the palate supplemented by rich honeydew and green apple. Tempered by a prominent vein of acidity, the wine closes at length with a seamless silk-like quality, finishing wit h pleasing minerality.”

This was the last (only) bottle in the Sobito cellar collection. 

Grayish straw colored with slight olive green hue, medium to full bodied, sharp acidity and mineral notes, a bit flabby lacking definition, a cacophony of golden apple and green apple fruits with hints of citrus,  honeydew and notes of vanilla and nutty cashew on a subdued pointed finish. 

RM 88 points. 

https://go.cellartracker.com/wine/4518244

https://www.orinswift.com/